Choose a row to list only the reviews with that rating.
Ratings by aspect
Each aspect gets a score of its own after 5 customers have rated it.
Particulars
The entry for Welcome Wagon
Founded in 1928, Welcome Wagon is one of America's most recognized new mover marketing companies, helping businesses connect with consumers during the critical first weeks and months after a move. Through targeted direct mail, digital marketing, and multichannel campaigns, Welcome Wagon helps businesses reach new movers as they establish relationships with local providers and make purchasing decisions. Serving thousands of markets across the United States and connecting brands with more than one million consumers each month, the company remains committed to helping businesses acquire new customers, build brand awareness, and foster long-term customer relationships
Register summary for Welcome Wagon (welcomewagon.com): 270 published reviews, rated 4.3 out of 5 on average.
Since I’ve lived at the same address for 13+ years I have no idea why I just received a “new movers” package full of info/coupons I would never use in a million years anyway. I’d really like to know how I got on their list. It seems like potential fraud is going on somehow, though I can’t see how specifically.
Filed by Margaret A.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Oct 15, 2026
Thank you for sharing this, and we apologize for the confusion. Our new mover program relies on public and commercial data sources, and occasionally an address is included in error. We'd be glad to look into it and make sure you don't receive future mailings. Please contact us at [email protected] so you can give us more details and we'll gladly take care of it.
Filed
Don't waste your time or money on this…
Don't waste your time or money on this company. We got zero leads out of this over a 2 year period. The only reason we even went with a second year is because their contract renews and you have no idea. They are completely unresponsive when you need help or want information. They are really good at harassing you for payment though.
Filed by Pez L.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Oct 15, 2026
Thank you for sharing this, and we are sorry your experience fell short of what you expected — that is not the experience we want for any of our partners.
For you and for others reading: our advertising agreements are for a fixed term, listed on the signed insertion form. Where an agreement includes automatic renewal, it renews for the same length of time unless we receive written notice at least 30 days before the term ends. Partners can send that notice, or ask about their renewal date, at any time at [email protected]. We know contract terms are easy to lose track of over a year, and we want every partner to know exactly where they stand before a renewal happens.
I'd like to personally review your account, including how your program performed and how your renewal was communicated, and talk it through with you directly. Please contact me at [email protected] with the best way to reach you.
Filed
An ineffective and dishonest business...
I’m extremely disappointed with how this has been handled. We had a local representative at the beginning—right up until I agreed to sign up—and then she completely disappeared. The service itself was ineffective; the stats provided were inaccurate, and we did not receive a single prospect or member through Welcome Wagon platform. To make matters worse, it has been nearly impossible to reach anyone in customer service to cancel the subscription. Due to the lack of response and support, I was left with no choice but to ask my bank to stop the payments
Filed by Maryam F.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Apr 30, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. I’m very sorry to hear that this was your impression—especially regarding communication and support, as that’s something we take seriously.
What you’ve described is not the experience we aim to provide. Our intent is for every client to have consistent access to both their local representative and our Customer Support team throughout the duration of their program. If that did not happen in your case, we want to understand why and address it.
In terms of performance, our program is designed to deliver consistent exposure to new movers, with verified reporting tied to distribution. While results can vary based on factors like offer, timing, and category, we never want a client to feel that the value or reporting was unclear, and we are always available to walk through those details.
We also want to clarify for transparency that our agreements are structured as fixed-term programs rather than subscriptions, which is outlined at the time of enrollment.
That said, your feedback matters. We would appreciate the opportunity to review your account and better understand what occurred so we can address it appropriately. Please contact us at [email protected], and we will make this a priority.
Filed
Sent me unsolicited mail
Sent me unsolicited mail. Have no idea who these guys are or how they got my info. Creeps
Filed by Consumer
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Apr 30, 2026
We understand how receiving unexpected mail can feel frustrating, and we appreciate you sharing your concern.
Welcome Wagon sends mail to new residents using data from a variety of standard, compliant sources such as public records, change-of-address filings, and new utility connections. This allows local businesses to introduce themselves to people who have recently moved into the area.
That said, we respect your preferences. If you would prefer not to receive future mailings, we’re happy to take care of that for you. Please reach out to us at [email protected], and we will ensure your information is removed from future distributions.
Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
Filed
Well their service was great until year…
Well their service was great until year 2. I have to take responsibility for not reading their contract. But the contract has VERY steep penalties.
First I didn't know that I was automatically being re-enrolled every year. And once I received my bill and tried to cancel, they told me that I was committed for another year of over $3000. The only thing they could offer me is an early cancelation fee of over $1500 plus the amount of my 2-month bill.
Finally I never got any clients from their service that I know of. So in San DIego, I wouldn't recommend WW.
Filed by Presto C.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Apr 30, 2026
Thank you for sharing your experience. I’m glad to hear the program met your expectations initially, but I’m sorry to hear that your experience in year two led to frustration—especially around the agreement terms and renewal.
For transparency, our programs are structured as fixed-term agreements with renewal provisions outlined in the Terms & Conditions at the time of signing. We understand that contract details can sometimes be overlooked, which is why we aim to make those terms as clear as possible upfront and through renewal communications.
Regarding performance, while our program is designed to provide consistent exposure to new movers, results can vary based on factors like offer, timing, and category. That said, we never want a client to feel uncertain about value, and we do offer reporting and support to help track and optimize performance over time.
We also understand that situations like this can feel frustrating, and while we do operate within the terms of the agreement, our goal is always to work with clients in a fair and reasonable way.
We would welcome the opportunity to review your account and see if there’s anything further we can do. Please reach out to us at [email protected], and we’ll make this a priority.
Filed
Good People, Terrible Business
The only reason this is a 2 star instead of 0 stars is because of the people I dealt with throughout who were very responsive and accommodative. Otherwise this is a massive case of over promise and under deliver. There's a reason they lock you in for a full 12 months. They know you'll want out sooner.
I went above and beyond and sent each monthly contact a personal card. What did I get for my time effort and money? 1 contact in 12 months. I've never seen less effective marketing efforts.
Also I got back on average 7 of my cards each month with bad or incomplete addresses and a few people told me the information was outdated by years. I had to get them to refund the bad names I knew about which they did but only after I asked/insisted. They know what comes back and good, honest service would credit bad names automatically.
At the end of the day, my experience was a highly negative one. They took my money and ran without having to deliver any results over a 12 month period. Not all industries are the same but this is one of my biggest marketing regrets so far.
Filed by Tyler J.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Feb 3, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We’re truly sorry to hear that the program did not meet your expectations, and we appreciate you acknowledging the responsiveness and professionalism of the team you worked with.
Welcome Wagon programs are designed to introduce businesses to new residents over the full term of the agreement. While many advertisers see positive engagement, outcomes such as leads or sales can vary significantly by industry, market conditions, timing, and offer, and are not guaranteed. Services are fulfilled as outlined in the agreement rather than based on a specific volume of responses.
Address accuracy is an important concern, and when issues are identified, our Customer Service team does review and address them in accordance with our policies. We appreciate you bringing those instances to our attention so they could be evaluated and resolved.
We understand your frustration and regret that your experience was a negative one. Feedback like yours is taken seriously and shared internally as we continue working to improve transparency, expectations, and advertiser experience.
Thank you again for sharing your perspective.
Filed
Do not waste your money
This is the most overpriced, worthless marketing Ive done in the past 25 years. NOT 1 CALL/EMAIL/CLICK = NOTHING!
I found the same info plus emails and phone #'s for 10 cents/name... thats 10$ vs $500... absolutely worthless
Filed by Nick S.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Feb 13, 2026
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We understand how disappointing it can be when advertising does not produce the results you were expecting, and we appreciate the opportunity to respond.
Thank you for speaking with our account manager in Customer Service to review your concerns, along with options to help maximize the remainder of your campaign, while continuing to fulfill all services outlined in the agreement. Delivery and distribution have been completed as contracted.
As with any form of advertising or data-driven marketing, results cannot be guaranteed. While we provide exposure to targeted new-mover households and access to distribution data intended to support outreach, customer response is influenced by many factors outside of our control, including timing, market conditions, and individual consumer decisions.
We respect that our program may not be the right fit for every business and appreciate your feedback. We wish you success in your future marketing efforts.
Filed
Miserable experience with this company
Miserable experience with this company. When I first learned about their story, I was really excited. I pressed hard to become a community representative. I very quickly rose to the top ranks of the company's sales leaders. Then, I began to receive calls from my clients. Every single one of them was frustrated. Not a single one experienced positive ROI from their investment. The company's response was to say, "We don't guarantee results." I ended up personally paying the balance of their monthly fees for the remainder of their annual commitment. It cost me tens of thousands of dollars to retain my clients' trust. Really expensive, but worth keeping my solid, trusting relationships with them.
Filed by Jim R.
Reply from Welcome Wagon· Oct 7, 2025
We appreciate your time with Welcome Wagon and wish you continued success in your future endeavors. We’d like to provide clarity for those reading this review, as the information shared does not accurately reflect our company’s practices or client support process.
Welcome Wagon has been America’s Welcoming Service since 1928, and our approach has always centered on consultative, long-term partnerships with the businesses we serve. From the initial presentation, we ensure every client clearly understands the structure of their program, the marketing provisions included, and the expected timeline for visibility and engagement results.
It is not our practice to ask or expect representatives to personally pay client fees. Our company has a dedicated Customer Service and Sales Support team in place to assist clients with any concerns and to ensure satisfaction throughout their campaign. In this situation, the appropriate customer-service channels were not utilized, and the matters referenced were never escalated for resolution through our management or support departments.
While we respect your experience, our focus remains on maintaining transparency, accountability, and the highest standard of client care. We’re proud of our team, our support systems, and the measurable success that thousands of our business partners continue to see through their Welcome Wagon programs.